Cheap flights from New York City to Caribbean

Travel > Caribbean

Check our current prices for flights from New York City to Caribbean. Please note that we also give you historical search data for this city connection. These are all airfares that people found in the past, in order to find more current flight information from New York City to Caribbean, you will need to run a search below.

Search and Compare cheap Flights

Enter your travel details:Step 1

Flight only
Flight + HotelSave up to 30% on vacations

From (city or airport):
Rooms: 1 2 3 4 5 6
Travelers: 1 2 3 4 5 6
To (city or airport):
Depart (mm/dd/yyyy):
Return (mm/dd/yyyy):
Weekly newsletter (optional)

Select merchants to compare:Step 2

 

From $256 / RT details

Book your flight now with Cheapoair.com and save!

Cheap San Juan airfares from $256/RT are provided by Cheapoair.com. Outbound flight is leaving on 07/09/2025, 06:00 am from New York Ny/newark Newark Inl (EWR) airport and arrives at San Juan Marin Intl (SJU) at 10:01 am. The flight time is 4 hours and 1 minutes. The Returning flight departes on 07/15/2025, 09:30 pm (other return dates are also available). Date posted: 23 Feb 2025

Price evolution for flights From New York City To Caribbean

Recent Deals on Flights from New York City to Caribbean:Roundtrip / Oneway

• $256 Frontier Airlines 

  From	To	Departure	Time
  Newark, NJ (EWR)	San Juan, PR (SJU)	07/09/2025	06:00 am
  San Juan, PR (SJU)	Newark, NJ (EWR)	07/15/2025	09:30 pm

  cheapoair.com check price
• $356 Frontier Airlines 

  From	To	Departure	Time
  Newark, NJ (EWR)	Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	05/28/2025	06:00 am
  Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	Newark, NJ (EWR)	06/10/2025	01:52 pm

  cheapoair.com check price
• $383 Multiple Airlines 

  From	To	Departure	Time
  New York, NY (LGA)	Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	05/28/2025	06:00 pm
  Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	New York, NY (LGA)	06/10/2025	01:52 pm

  cheapoair.com check price
• $395 Multiple Airlines 

  From	To	Departure	Time
  Newark, NJ (EWR)	San Juan, PR (SJU)	07/09/2025	09:00 am
  San Juan, PR (SJU)	Newark, NJ (EWR)	07/15/2025	07:45 am

  cheapoair.com check price
• $411 Multiple Airlines 

  From	To	Departure	Time
  Newark, NJ (EWR)	Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	05/28/2025	05:04 pm
  Santo Domingo, DO (SDQ)	Newark, NJ (EWR)	06/10/2025	01:52 pm

  cheapoair.com check price
• We are sorry but currently there are no oneway offers for flights from New York City to Caribbean.
  Please visit this page again later or try out our merchant comparison search. Good luck!